Duke University Chronicle, September 1, 1983

From The Elvis Costello Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
- Bibliography -
1975767778798081
8283848586878889
9091929394959697
9899000102030405
0607080910111213
14151617 18 19 20 21


Duke University Chronicle

North Carolina publications

US publications by state
  • ALAK  AR  AZCA
  • COCTDCDEFL
  • GAHA   IA      ID      IL
  • IN   KSKYLA   MA
  • MDME   MIMNMO
  • MSMTNC  ND    NE
  • NHNJNMNVNY
  • OHOKORPARI
  • SCSDTNTXUT
  • VAVTWAWIWY

-

Elvis' 'Punch the Clock' not up to par


Jason Strominger

Elvis Costello's Punch The Clock is an album that is at best a mediocre followup to his masterpiece, Imperial Bedroom. That is not to say that this album is a throwaway; there are a few high points. Unfortunately, the high points are few.

On this release, Costello, who has been touted by many critics as the best songwriter of the current generation, gives us a poor example of his talent. As an Elvis fan, I was disappointed to find this new selection of songs lacking in coherence and direction. What Costello does in the space of a little over 40 minutes is list his views on everything from love in relationships (in "Mouth Almighty") to hate in relationships ("Charm School") to contempt for the government ("Pills and Soap") and abhorrence of war ("Shipbuilding"). What results from this verbal overkill is a muddled message that confuses the listener.

Although Costello is not generally known for sticking to one theme per album — it was on Imperial Bedroom where he first used a single theme and consequently ended up with a classic disc — he is known for his abundant supply of catchy hooks and melodies. Unfortunately, few of these are found on this record.

With the exception of three songs, the album doesn't have any tunes that instantly catch the ear. Although you may find yourself immediately humming to the pump-it-up chorus of "Let Them All Talk," the swing phrasing of "Everyday I Write The Book," or the crooning verses of "Mouth Almighty," there is little else that is memorable. Even the poignant anti-war ballad "Shipbuilding" — originally written as a protest against the Falkland Islands War — has no real chorus and just seems to uncomfortably fade out.

One interesting but not necessarily beneficial addition on this album is TKO, a four-piece horn section that accompanies Elvis' already superb backup band, The Attractions. TKO's job seems to be to make the songs swing in the fashion of Frank Sinatra or Mel Torme, but often they fail to add anything interesting. The idea is great, and it does work effectively in spots, like in "Let Them All Talk," but they should be used more sparingly. In the songs "TKO" and "Invisible Man" the horns tend to get annoying by distracting the listener from serious lyrics.

A word should also be said about the lyrics on the album. Elvis' inclusion of a lyrics sheet in Punch the Clock is certainly a plus, because with a singer like Costello, the words are a vital part of the music, and that is said is sometimes lost in the singer's accent or in the mix. However, this album's lyrics are definitely not up to Elvis' reputation for excellence. The images and symbols he employs, as well as his puns and tricks in wording, tend to be ambiguous. For example, in "Let Them All talk" he says, "Hear what I say / See what I do / Believe me now I'm all over you."

It's hard to tell if what he wants us to do is to take him literally or if he is telling us that he has just called it quits with his latest flame. In "The King Of Thieves" and "The Invisible Man," Elvis does not give as a hint at who the king of thieves is nor why he wants to be invisible. "Everyday I Write The Book," which is receiving a lot of airplay, is a nonsense song that has no apparent meaning. The same can be said of "The World And His Wife."

Even more so than on Imperial Bedroom, Costello on this album has lost the cutting edge that was once so prominent in the lyrics of his early albums. Maybe it is just because Elvis has mellowed out, no longer finding use for the angry young man pose he formerly flaunted.

This album should not be used as an introduction to Elvis Costello's music. It simply is not one of his better records. However, it is still worth the attention of an Elvis fan.

-

The Chronicle, R&R, September 1, 1983


Jason Strominger reviews Punch The Clock.


Reader Mark Miller responds in a subsequent edition.

Images

1983-09-01 Duke University Chronicle R&R page 03 clipping 01.jpg
Clipping.



The Chronicle, September 16, 1983

An immortal Elvis


Mark Miller

1983-09-16 Duke University Chronicle R&R page 12 clipping 01.jpg

To the editorial board:

On reading Jason Strominger's article "Elvis' Punch the Clock' not up to par," I was shocked to find such a derogatory and downright blasphemous critique of yet another Elvis masterpiece.

The album's high points are far from being scanty — they follow each other in close succession. If the phrase "catches the ear" has any relevance at all considering the broad range of tastes in listener, then nearly every song catches my ear.

The addition of TKO does not hinder or tarnish Elvis' style in the least, but rather signifies a successful experimentation in style which demonstrates his ability to turn to gold every musical genre he touches.

The brass section does not distract the listener from "serious lyrics," which are elsewhere in the article labeled as being ambiguous and nonsensical. Granted, all of Elvis' lyrics are somewhat lacking in concrete significance, but it is with his apparent vagueness that Elvis rises above the common rabble of Top Forty teeny-hopper love tunes and party songs. Elvis' lyrics can mean almost anything to anybody, and it is up to each individual listener to assign them meaning.

Who are we, as mere mortals, to judge the immortal and infallible Elvis Costello? He is perhaps the only savior for the current music market, and is undoubtedly the best songwriter of this generation.



1983-09-01 Duke University Chronicle R&R page 03.jpg
Page scan.

-



Back to top

External links