London Independent, May 28, 2009

From The Elvis Costello Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
... Bibliography ...
727677787980818283
848586878889909192
939495969798990001
020304050607080910
111213141516171819
202122232425 26 27 28


London Independent

UK & Ireland newspapers

-

Secret, Profane & Sugarcane

Elvis Costello

Andy Gill

Elvis Costello albums seem to arrive with increasing frequency these days, their diversity appearing more like compensation for their patchiness.

If you didn't like him singing with a string quartet, maybe you'd care for him in a jazz suite? No? How about collaborations with Burt Bacharach? Allen Toussaint? Anne Sophie von Otter? Or, as here, hooking up with T Bone Burnette for some of those rootsy string-band settings that proved popular for Plant & Krauss?

Though far from the most daunting prospect in his sprawling catalogue, this proves no better in practice, partly because Costello's voice has a mean-spirited tone devoid of the siren lure of Plant & Krauss's harmonies, and it's a rag-bag of material that simply doesn't hang together. There's a bluegrass cover of "Complicated Shadows," from 1996's All This Useless Beauty; a fast string-band shuffle of "Hidden Shame," written for Johnny Cash; several tedious, self-pitying romantic country pastiches, one ("I Felt The Chill") co-written with Loretta Lynn; and four tracks written for an abortive opera project about Hans Christian Andersen's love affair with singer Jenny Lind. But it's a shoddy set of barrel-scrapings overall, lacking both focus and impetus.

Download this: "Red Cotton," "The Crooked Line"


Tags:  Secret, Profane & SugarcaneT Bone BurnettLoretta LynnI Felt The Chill Before The Winter CameComplicated ShadowsHidden ShameJohnny CashRed CottonThe Crooked LineThe Secret SongsHans Christian AndersenJenny LindAll This Useless BeautyAnne Sofie von OtterBurt BacharachAllen ToussaintRobert PlantAlison Krauss

-
<< >>

The Independent, May 28, 2009


Andy Gill reviews Secret, Profane & Sugarcane.

Images

Secret Profane & Sugarcane album cover.jpg

-



Back to top

External links