Quora, January 2, 2019

From The Elvis Costello Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
... Bibliography ...

  • 2019 January 2



Armed Forces

Elvis Costello and The Attractions

George B. Seitz

What is your review of Elvis Costello's 1979 album, Armed Forces?

It could be said that Elvis Costello had the distinct pleasure of living out the ultimate dream of every sharp-witted, incurably bitter young person with hopes of achieving stardom. Virtually overnight, he established himself as among the most articulate songwriters rock music has ever seen, infusing punk with the literacy it had always strived for but rarely achieved. With superstar status and a reputation for pushing the envelope, Costello was able to crystallize the thematic threads of political and personal devastation that ran through his first two records into the concept of emotional fascism, for his third album named Armed Forces.

As Costello writes in the liner notes to this expanded reissue, Armed Forces marks the first time that he was actually aware of his audience. Perhaps in an attempt to elucidate the web of veiled and convoluted social and personal references running through his first two records, the album is lyrically much more general, and remarkably self-conscious, right from the opening lyric, "Oh, I just don't know where to begin." This, of course, doesn't slow Costello down — "Accidents Will Happen," one of the finest songs in his, or any, repertoire, matches a signature smirking double-entendre with an almost Baroque pop sensibility. Melodically and lyrically, the song is above reproach, as Costello sings of infidelity with what could either be construed as regret or smug satisfaction. It's also one of several songs on Armed Forces to benefit from the album's dense production.

Armed Forces is extravagantly layered with dense instrumentation and rich, effusive textures. Pete Thomas' maniacal drumming is much more consistent than on previous outings, and keyboardist Steve Nieve, for the first time, is as likely to be found at a piano as behind a synthesizer. On "Accidents Will Happen" and the similarly stunning "Oliver's Army," in which Costello winds catchy and elegant melodies around slightly off-kilter chord progressions, the production works to the record's advantage, filling the songs out with bombastic power-pop arrangements and giving weight to their urgency. "Big Boys" and "Green Shirt" — two subdued products of the same mold that produced "The Beat" and "Pump It Up," and make full use of steady, insistent rhythms and the unstoppable kinetic energy of The Attractions — are near-classics as well, but are somewhat hindered by the album's smoother production.

In the end, the greatest strength of Armed Forces may be the same thing that makes it less viscerally powerful than Costello's two prior records — its songs absolutely demand to be appreciated for their craftsmanship. In many ways, Armed Forces can be seen as the point at which Costello dropped the role of angry young upstart, and became more comfortable with his personification as a songwriter. And considering that he has since remained largely true to this sound, it can be seen not only as the consummation of all he had worked toward, but a window to what he would later accomplish.

Tags: Emotional FascismArmed ForcesThe AttractionsAccidents Will HappenPete ThomasSteve NieveOliver's ArmyBig BoysGreen ShirtThe BeatPump It UpArmed Forces (2002) liner notesPower pop


Quora, January 2, 2019

George B. Seitz reviews Armed Forces.


Armed Forces UK album cover.jpg


Back to top

External links