Musician, May 1990: Difference between revisions
(+text part 1) |
(+text part 2) |
||
Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
{{Bibliography article header}} | {{Bibliography article header}} | ||
<center><h3> Elvis Costello on McCartney / MacManus </h3></center> | <center><h3> Elvis Costello on McCartney / MacManus </h3></center> | ||
<center> Opposites attract - and repel - in a dream songwriting collaboration </center> | |||
---- | ---- | ||
<center> Bill Flanagan </center> | <center> Bill Flanagan </center> | ||
---- | ---- | ||
{{Bibliography text}} | {{Bibliography text}} | ||
Paul McCartney spent more than two years on the different recording sessions that eventually evolved into ''Flowers in the Dirt''. He worked with different producers at different times, recording and stockpiling songs. The most publicized collaboration was with Elvis Costello. Over the course of a year the two Liverpudlians wrote an album's worth of songs and then went into the studio to let Costello try his hand at producing McCartney: "It was very interesting," says Hamish Stuart, who joined the sessions during that period. "Elvis and Paul started off producing together. Certain things happened that eventually benefited the project, but I don't think the co-production worked out as a whole. Elvis' thinking might have been just a little too radical. Once Elvis said, 'Let's double-track this background vocal, then we'll bounce it down a couple of times to lose some quality.' And he was serious! The whole studio fell apart when he said it. Everybody jumped on it. That became sort of a running joke. I don't think it stopped Elvis' ideas, though. But certain things Elvis said and certain things they did together remained there in the end product. And I think even Elvis' thinking changed when he did his own record [''Spike''], 'cause it's so much more sonically happening. He usually goes for a garage thing." | |||
"In the studio," Costello says, "Paul has a clever way of sidestepping confrontation by making jokes like, 'Well, you can never trust anything he says 'cause he hates effects!' So rather than disagreeing with you, your argument's devalued before it's started. After a while that made the production kind of redundant" | |||
The McCartney sessions done with Costello survived on ''Flowers in the Dirt'' to some degree, though in the months after Costello left the project the tapes were overdubbed and added to by McCartney and the next producer at bat, Mitchell Froom. Finally, when McCartney decided it was time to get the album finished, he brought in super producer Neil Dorfsman (Dire Straits, Sting) to get the whole thing organized. "Neil pulled everything together," Stuart says. "There had been so many producers, so many people working on the record, that they needed one person to mix it. Neil was the guy." | |||
Costello's influence is still apparent, though, particularly in "That Day Is Done," the song from which the album draws its title. That tune takes the album's maturity to its logical conclusion — the grave. In the tradition of country songs like "Long Black Veil," "That Day Is Done" is sung by a ghost to the young woman crying over his resting place as "she sprinkles flowers in the dirt." "I must give Elvis a lot of credit for 'That Day Is Done,'" McCartney says. "His grandmother was dying in Ireland and a lot of this 'Long Black Coat'-ness came from that fact. We wrote it together, but I must give him a lot of credit for that. I'm well into it, I really enjoyed making the record. My elderly housekeeper Rose, who wouldn't like me to tell her age, heard it and she said to Linda, 'Is that him, Lin? No! Is that him?' She was totally into it. For hours she wouldn't believe it was me!" | |||
We spoke to Costello in Ireland, where he was unpacking belongings in his new home. He had just found an autograph book from his childhood. Costello's father, Ross MacManus, a well-known British band singer, performed on a bill with the Beatles in 1963. Ross brought home the Beatles' autographs for his son that night. Twenty-six years later, Elvis had just found them again. | |||
''You suggested McCartney play the Beatles bass part on "My Brace Face"? | |||
In the studio he had this five-string bass, which you can gel some great lines on — but I was trying all along to say that having a very recognizable, unique style of playing is not something to be sniffed at No other bass player would approach the parts quite the same way. I think sometimes when you're very close to things, you're aware of them as mannerisms. I know that I have it with my voice and even to some extent with the very limited guitar that I play; I'm sometimes reluctant to put the bit in because it sounds too much like ''me''. Maybe Paul sometimes shies away from doing things that come naturally. I couldn't take credit for the figure [in "My Brave Face" I just said, "A cross figure in the 'Taxman'/'Paperback Writer' vein would be a good thing." | |||
It's as much a signature as the sound of his voice. I think it's a hard thing to work out a signature part like that. He's obviously a very fluent musician, he could work out any number of parts in many different styles. The important thing was to get the one that sounded like him. It's very difficult. I remember after the pictures on my first record, people would say to me, "Go on, do the funny legs!" It's like going up to Woody Allen and saying, "Go on, be funny." Once you say it to somebody they can't do it. It can get a bit insulting if you keep cajoling people, 'cause it starts to suggest that everything they do is a cliché. That was certainly not my intention. It would be really worthwhile putting in the record. I started writing the bridge of "My Brave Face," that Beatle-y descending "Ever since you've been away..." We were doing a vocal rehearsal in the kitchen and he sang the line, "Take me to that place." I hit the low harmony on "place" and he went, "Oh no, no. This is getting to be too much. That's exactly like 'There's a Place' or 'I'll Get You.'" As my voice is harsher than his and in a lower register, it does do that same thing. Those comparisons can be a drag, but they're so sweet on the ear you can't help slipping into them. And I notice he kept it on the record! | |||
''Paul gave you a lot of credit for "That Day Is Done." | |||
I remember one review said, "It's very hard to imagine any Paul McCartney song opening, 'I feel such sorrow, I feel such shame.'" Obviously the lyrical root of that song started with me. But it would have been a very plain, probably not very memorable gospel song if there hadn't been a strong chorus on it, which is what Paul said immediately: "It's got to have a chorus!" I was quite happy for it to have the detail of the verses and pay it off with just the title line, but he said, "No, you've got to develop that title line and repeat it musically. Then you end up with a song of more substance." | |||
{{cx}} | {{cx}} | ||
{{rttc}} | |||
{{Bibliography notes header}} | {{Bibliography notes header}} |
Revision as of 00:06, 4 June 2014
|